Toxic chemicals used in product design and manufacturing are grave concerns due to their toxic impact on human health. Implementing sustainable material selection strategies on toxic chemicals can substantially improve the sustainability of products in both design and manufacturing processes. In this paper, a schematic method is presented for characterizing and benchmarking the human health impact of toxic chemicals, as a visual aid to facilitate decision-making in the material selection process for sustainable design and manufacturing. In this schematic method, the human health impact of a toxic chemical is characterized by two critical parameters: daily exposure risk and environmental persistence . The human health impact of a toxic chemical is represented by its position in the two-dimensional plot, which enables the screening and benchmarking of toxic chemicals to be easily made through comparing their relative positions in the characterization plot. A case study is performed on six toxic chemicals commonly used as solvents for cleaning and degreasing in product development and manufacturing.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
1.
U.S. EPA
, “Toxic Release Inventory (TRI)
,” http://www.epa.gov/tri/chemical/index.htmhttp://www.epa.gov/tri/chemical/index.htm2.
European Environmental Agency (EEA)
, 2003, “The European Pollutant Emission Register
,” http://eper.eea.europa.eu/eper/http://eper.eea.europa.eu/eper/, accessed on 10/18/09.3.
OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development)
, 2001, “Why Pollutant Release and Transfer Registers (PRTRs) Differ: A Review of National Programmes. ENV/jm/mono (2001)16
,” OECD Environment, Health, and Safety Publications, Series on Pollutant Release and Transfer Registers No. 4 Paris: OECD
.4.
Holloway
, L.
, 1998, “Materials Selection for Optimal Environmental Impact in Mechanical Design
,” Mater. Des.
0264-1275, 19
, pp. 133
–143
.5.
Ljungberg
, L. Y.
, 2007, “Materials Selection and Design for Development of Sustainable Products
,” Mater. Des.
0264-1275, 28
, pp. 466
–479
.6.
Matos
, M. J.
, and Simplicio
, M. H.
, 2006, “Innovation and Sustainability in Mechanical Design Through Materials Selection
,” Mater. Des.
0264-1275, 27
, pp. 74
–78
.7.
Wegst
, U. G. K.
, and Ashby
, M. F.
, 1998, “The Development and Use of a Methodology for the Environmentally Conscious Selection of Materials
,” Proceedings of the Third Biennial World Conference on Integrated Design and Process Technology (IDPT)
, Berlin, Germany, Jul. 6–9, Vol. 5
, pp. 88
–93
.8.
Risitano
, A.
, Rosa
, G. L.
, and Giudice
, F.
, 2005, “Materials Selection in the Life Cycle Design Process: A Method to Integrate Mechanical and Environmental Performances in Optimal Choice
,” Mater. Des.
0264-1275, 26
, pp. 9
–20
.9.
Tong
, T. K. L.
, and Chan
, J. W. K.
, 2007, “Multi-Criteria Material Selections and End-of-Life Product Strategy: Grey Relational Analysis Approach
,” Mater. Des.
0264-1275, 28
, pp. 1539
–1546
.10.
Lin
, F.
, and Lin
, L.
, 2003, “A Discussion of the State-of-Art Research on Environmentally Conscious Material Selection Methodologies for the Reduction of Products’ Toxic Impact
,” The Journal of Sustainable Product Design
, 3
, pp. 119
–134
.11.
Ashby
, M.
, 2005, Materials Selection in Mechanical Design
, 3rd ed., Elsevier
, New York
.12.
Brechet
, Y.
, Bassetti
, D.
, Landru
, D.
, and Salvo
, L.
, 2001, “Challenges in Materials and Process Selection
,” Prog. Mater. Sci.
0079-6425, 46
, pp. 407
–428
.13.
Srikar
, V. T.
, and Spearing
, S. M.
, 2003, “Materials Selection in Micromechanical Design: An Application of the Ashby Approach
,” J. Microelectromech. Syst.
1057-7157, 12
(1
), pp. 3
–10
.14.
Weaver
, P. M.
, Ashby
, M. F.
, Burgess
, S.
, and Shibaike
, N.
, 1996, “Selection of Materials to Reduce Environmental Impact: A Case Study on Refrigerator Insulation
,” Mater. Des.
0264-1275, 17
(1
), pp. 11
–17
.15.
Jee
, D. H.
, and Kang
, K. J.
, 2000, “A Method for Optimal Material Selection Aided With Decision Making Theory
,” Mater. Des.
0264-1275, 21
, pp. 199
–206
.16.
Yuan
, C.
, and Dornfeld
, D.
, 2009, “Sustainable Material Selection of Toxic Chemicals in Design and Manufacturing From Human Health Impact Perspective
,” ASME
Paper No. DETC 2009-87145.17.
Liao
, T. W.
, 1996, “A Fuzzy Multicriteria Decision-Making Method for Material Selection
,” J. Manuf. Syst.
0278-6125, 15
(1
), pp. 1
–12
.18.
Goel
, V.
, and Chen
, J.
, 1996, “Application of Expert Network for Material Selection in Engineering Design
,” Comput Ind.
0166-3615, 30
, pp. 87
–101
.19.
Sirisalee
, P.
, Ashby
, M. F.
, Parks
, G. T.
, and Clarkson
, P. J.
, 2004, “Multi-Criteria Material Selection in Engineering Design
,” Adv. Eng. Mater.
1438-1656, 6
(1–2
), pp. 84
–92
.20.
Giachetti
, R. E.
, 1998, “A Decision Support System for Material and Manufacturing Process Selection
,” J. Intell. Manuf.
0956-5515, 9
, pp. 265
–276
.21.
Jia
, C. Q.
, Guardo
, A. D.
, and Mackay
, D.
, 1996, “Toxics Release Inventories: Opportunities for Improved Presentation and Interpretation
,” Environ. Sci. Technol.
0013-936X, 30
(2
), pp. 86A
–91A
.22.
Hertwich
, E. G.
, Pease
, W. S.
, and McKone
, T. E.
, 1998, “Evaluating Toxic Impact Assessment Methods: What Works Best?
,” Environ. Sci. Technol.
0013-936X, 32
(5
), pp. 138A
–144A
.23.
Toffel
, M. W.
, and Marshall
, J. D.
, 2004, “Improving Environmental Performance Assessment: Comparative Analysis of Weighting Methods Used to Evaluate Chemical Release Inventories
,” J. Ind. Ecol.
1088-1980, 8
(1–2
), pp. 143
–172
.24.
Fava
, J.
, Consoli
, F.
, Denison
, R.
, Dickson
, K.
, Mohin
, T.
, and Vigon
, B.
, 1992, A Conceptual Framework for Life Cycle Impact Assessment
, SETAC
, Pensacola, FL
.25.
Pennington
, D. W.
, and Yue
, P. L.
, 2000, “Options for Comparison of Process Design Alternatives in Terms of Regional Environmental Impacts
,” J. Cleaner Prod.
0959-6526, 8
, pp. 1
–9
.26.
Hertwich
, E. G.
, Mateles
, S. F.
, Pease
, W. S.
, and McKone
, T. E.
, 2001, “Human Toxicity Potentials for Life-Cycle Assessment and Toxics Release Inventory Risk Screening
,” Envir. Toxicol. Chem.
0730-7268, 20
(4
), pp. 928
–939
.27.
Huijbregts
, M. A. J.
, Thissen
, U.
, Guinée
, J.
, Jager
, T.
, Kalf
, D.
, Meent
, D.
, Ragas
, A. M. J.
, Sleeswijk
, A. W.
, and Reijnders
, L.
, 2000, “Priority Assessment of Toxic Substances in Life Cycle Assessment. Part I: Calculation of Toxicity Potentials for 181 Substances With the Nested Multi-Media Fate, Exposure and Effects Model USES-LCA
,” Chemosphere
0045-6535, 41
(4
), pp. 541
–573
.28.
Horvath
, A.
, Hendrickson
, C. T.
, Lave
, L. B.
, McMichael
, F. C.
, and Wu
, T. S.
, 1995, “Toxic Emissions Indices for Green Design and Inventory
,” Environ. Sci. Technol.
0013-936X, 29
(2
), pp. 86A
–90A
.29.
Czeskleba-Dupont
, R.
, 1987, “A Comparison of Risk Assessments for Chlorinated Dioxings by ADI- Values and by Incremental Cancer Risk Estimates
,” Chemosphere
0045-6535, 16
(8–9
), pp. 2141
–2146
.30.
Lu
, F. C.
, and Sielken
, R. L.
, 1991, “Assessment of Safety/Risk of Chemicals: Inception and Evolution of the ADI and Dose-Response Modeling Procedures
,” Toxicol. Lett.
0378-4274, 59
, pp. 5
–40
.31.
Crettaz
, P.
, Pennington
, D.
, Rhomberg
, L.
, Brand
, K.
, and Jolliet
, O.
, 2002, “Assessing Human Health Response in Life Cycle Assessment Using ED10 and DALYs: Part 1—Cancer Effects
,” Risk Anal.
0272-4332, 22
(5
), pp. 931
–946
.32.
Pennington
, D.
, Crettza
, P.
, Tauxe
, A.
, Rhomberg
, L.
, Brand
, K.
, and Jolliet
, O.
, 2002, “Assessing Human Health Response in Life Cycle Assessment Using ED10 and DALYs: PART 2—Noncancer Effects
,” Risk Anal.
0272-4332, 22
(5
), pp. 947
–963
.33.
McKone
, T. E.
, Kyle
, A. D.
, Jolliet
, O.
, Olsen
, S. I.
, and Hauschild
, M.
, 2006, “Dose-Response Modeling for Life Cycle Impact Assessment: Findings of the Portland Review Workshop
,” Int. J. Life Cycle Assess.
0948-3349, 11
(2
), pp. 137
–140
.34.
Webster
, E.
, Mackay
, D.
, and Wania
, F.
, 1998, “Evaluating Environmental Persistence
,” Envir. Toxicol. Chem.
0730-7268, 17
, pp. 2148
–2158
.35.
Bennett
, D. H.
, Kastenberg
, W. E.
, and McKone
, T. E.
, 1999, “General Formulation of Characteristic Time for Persistent Chemicals in a Multimedia Environment
,” Environ. Sci. Technol.
0013-936X, 33
, pp. 503
–509
.36.
Bennett
, D. H.
, McKone
, T. E.
, and Kastenberg
, W. E.
, 2000, “Evaluating Multimedia Chemical Persistence: Classification and Regression Tree Analysis
,” Envir. Toxicol. Chem.
0730-7268, 19
, pp. 810
–819
.37.
Pennington
, D. W.
, 2001, “An Evaluation of Chemical Persistence Screening Approaches
,” Chemosphere
0045-6535, 44
, pp. 1589
–1601
.38.
MacLeod
, M.
, and McKone
, T.
, 2004, “Multimedia Persistence as an Indicator of Potential for Population Level Intake of Environmental Contaminants
,” Envir. Toxicol. Chem.
0730-7268, 23
(10
), pp. 2465
–2472
.39.
Mackay
, D.
, and Webster
, E.
, 2006, “Environmental Persistence of Chemicals
,” Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res.
0944-1344, 13
(1
), pp. 43
–49
.40.
Stroebe
, M.
, Scheringer
, M.
, and Hungerbuhler
, K.
, 2004, “Measures of Overall Persistence and the Temporal Remote State
,” Environ. Sci. Technol.
0013-936X, 38
(21
), pp. 5665
–5673
.41.
Yuan
, C. Y.
, and Dornfeld
, D. A.
, 2009, “Schematic Characterization of Human Health Impact of Toxic Chemicals for Sustainable Design and Manufacturing
,” Proceedings of IEEE International Symposium on Sustainable Systems and Technology
, Phoenix, AZ, May 18–20.42.
McKone
, T. E.
, and Enoch
, K. G.
, 2002, “CalTOX™, a Multimedia Total Exposure Model Version 4.0 (Beta)
,” Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, http://eetd.lbl.gov/ied/ERA/http://eetd.lbl.gov/ied/ERA/, accessed on 08/20/09.43.
Gold
, L. S.
, 2007, “The Carcinogenic Potency Database: Tetrachloroethylene
,” http://potency.berkeley.edu/chempages/TETRACHLOROETHYLENE.htmlhttp://potency.berkeley.edu/chempages/TETRACHLOROETHYLENE.html, accessed on 12/15/09.44.
Gaylor
, D. W.
, Chen
, J. J.
, and Sheehan
, D. M.
, 2006, “Uncertainty in Cancer Risk Estimates
,” Risk Anal.
0272-4332, 13
, pp. 149
–154
.45.
Baird
, S. J.
, Cohen
, J. T.
, Graham
, J. D.
, Shlyakheter
, A. I.
, and Evans
, J. S.
, 1996, “Noncancer Risk Assessment: A Probabilistic Alternative to Current Practice
,” Hum. Ecol. Risk Asses.
1080-7039, 2
, pp. 79
–102
.46.
Yuan
, Y.
, 2009, “A System Approach for Reducing the Environmental Impact of Manufacturing and Sustainability Improvement of Nano-Scale Manufacturing
,” Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley.Copyright © 2010
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
