Increasing the modularity of system architectures is generally accepted as a good design principle in engineering. In this paper, we explore whether modularity comes at the expense of robustness. To that end, we model three engineering systems as networks and measure the relation between modularity and robustness to random failures. We produced four types of network models of systems—component-component, component-function, component-parameter, and function-parameter—to further test the relation of robustness to the type of system representation, architectural or behavioral. The results show that higher modularity is correlated with lower robustness (p < 0.001) and that the estimated modularity of the system can depend on the type of system representation. The implication is that there is a tradeoff between modularity and robustness, meaning that increasing modularity might not be appropriate for systems for which robustness is critical and modularity estimates differ significantly between the types of system representation.
Issue Section:
Design Theory and Methodology
References
1.
Suh
, N.
, 2001
, Axiomatic Design: Advances and Applications
, Oxford University Press
, Oxford, UK
.2.
Skakoon
, J.
, 2008
, The Elements of Mechanical Design
, ASME Press
, New York
.3.
Tomayko
, J.
, 1985
, “Achieving Reliability—The Evolution of Redundancy in American Manned Spacecraft Computers
,” J. Br. Interplanet. Soc.
, 38
, pp. 545
–552
.https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=198600337454.
Baldwin
, C.
, and Clark
, K.
, 2000
, Design Rules: The Power of Modularity
, Vol. 1
, The MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
.5.
Gershenson
, J. K.
, and Prasad
, G. J.
, 1997
, “Modularity in Product Design for Manufacturability
,” Int. J. Agile Manuf.
, 1
(1
), pp. 99
–110
.http://pages.mtu.edu/~jkgershe/lel/research/IJAM'97.pdf6.
Baldwin
, C.
, and Clark
, K.
, 2006
, Modularity in the Design of Complex Engineering Systems
, Springer
, New York
, pp. 175
–205
.7.
Newcomb
, P. J.
, Bras
, B.
, and Rosen
, D. W.
, 1998
, “Implications of Modularity on Product Design for the Life Cycle
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 120
(3
), pp. 483
–490
.8.
Sarkar
, S.
, Dong
, A.
, Henderson
, J.
, and Robinson
, P.
, 2013
, “Spectral Characterization of Hierarchical Modularity in Product Architectures
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 136
(1
), p. 011006
.9.
Ulrich
, K.
, 1994
, Fundamentals of Product Modularity
, Springer
, New York
, pp. 219
–231
.10.
Hölttä-Otto
, K.
, and de Weck
, O.
, 2007
, “Degree of Modularity in Engineering Systems and Products With Technical and Business Constraints
,” Concurrent Eng.
, 15
(2
), pp. 113
–126
.11.
Bar-Yam
, Y.
, 2003
, “When Systems Engineering Fails-Toward Complex Systems Engineering
,” IEEE
International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics,
Vol. 2
, Washington, DC
, Oct. 5–8
, pp. 2021
–2028
. 12.
Taguchi
, G.
, Chowdhury
, S.
, and Taguchi
, S.
, 2000
, Robust Engineering
, McGraw-Hill Professional
, New York
.13.
Keshavarzi
, E.
, McIntire
, M.
, and Hoyle
, C.
, 2017
, “A Dynamic Design Approach Using the Kalman Filter for Uncertainty Management
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des., Anal. Manuf.
, 31
(2
), pp. 161
–172
.14.
Viana
, M. P.
, Tanck
, E.
, Beletti
, M. E.
, and da Fontoura Costa
, L.
, 2009
, “Modularity and Robustness of Bone Networks
,” Mol. BioSyst.
, 5
(3
), pp. 255
–261
.15.
Kitano
, H.
, 2004
, “Biological Robustness
,” Nat. Rev. Genet.
, 5
(11
), pp. 826
–837
.16.
Suyong
, E.
, Shin'ichi
, A.
, and Masayuki
, M.
, 2007
, “Toward Bio-Inspired Network Robustness—Step 1: Modularity
,” Second Bio-Inspired Models of Network, Information and Computing Systems
, Budapest, Hungary, Dec. 10–13, pp. 84
–87
.17.
Tran
, T.-D.
, and Kwon
, Y.-K.
, 2013
, “The Relationship Between Modularity and Robustness in Signalling Networks
,” J. R. Soc. Interface
, 10
(88
), p. 20130771
.18.
Holme
, P.
, 2011
, “Metabolic Robustness and Network Modularity: A Model Study
,” PLoS One
, 6
(2
), p. e16605
.19.
Beer
, S.
, 1972
, “Cybernetics—A Systems Approach to Management
,” Pers. Rev.
, 1
(2
), pp. 28
–39
.20.
Haley
, B.
, Dong
, A.
, and Tumer
, I. Y.
, 2016
, “A Comparison of Network-Based Metrics of Behavioral Degradation in Complex Engineered Systems
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 138
(12
), p. 121405
.21.
Walsh
, H.
, Dong
, A.
, and Tumer
, I. Y.
, 2018
, “The Role of Bridging Nodes in Behavioral Network Models of Complex Engineered Systems
,” Des. Sci.
, 4
, p. e8.22.
Haley
, B.
, Dong
, A.
, and Tumer
, I. Y.
, 2014
, “Creating Faultable Network Models of Complex Engineered Systems
,” ASME
Paper No. DETC2014-34407.23.
Walsh
, H. S.
, Dong
, A.
, and Tumer
, I. Y.
, 2017
, “The Structure of Vulnerable Nodes in Behavioral Network Models of Complex Engineered Systems
,” ASME
Paper No. DETC2017-67866.24.
Sosa
, M.
, Eppinger
, S.
, and Rowles
, C.
, 2007
, “A Network Approach to Define Modularity of Components in Complex Products
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 129
(11
), pp. 1118
–1129
.25.
Ma
, S.
, Jiang
, Z.
, and Liu
, W.
, 2016
, “A Design Change Analysis Model as a Change Impact Analysis Basis for Semantic Design Change Management
,” Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng., Part C
, 231
(13
), pp. 2384
–2397
.26.
Wang
, M.
, Sha
, Z.
, Huang
, Y.
, Contractor
, N.
, Fu
, Y.
, and Chen
, W.
, 2016
, “Forecasting Technological Impacts on Customers Co-Consideration Behaviors: A Data-Driven Network Analysis Approach
,” ASME
Paper No. DETC2016-60015.27.
Wang
, M.
, Chen
, W.
, Huang
, Y.
, Contractor
, N. S.
, and Fu
, Y.
, 2016
, “Modeling Customer Preferences Using Multidimensional Network Analysis in Engineering Design
,” Des. Sci.
, 2
, p. e11
.28.
Sosa
, M.
, Mihm
, J.
, and Browning
, T.
, 2011
, “Degree Distribution and Quality in Complex Engineered Systems
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 133
(10
), p. 101008
.29.
Baldwin
, C.
, MacCormack
, A.
, and Rusnak
, J.
, 2014
, “Hidden Structure: Using Network Methods to Map System Architecture
,” Res. Policy
, 43
(8
), pp. 1381
–1397
.30.
Sarkar
, S.
, Dong
, A.
, and Gero
, J. S.
, 2009
, “Design Optimization Problem (Re)-Formulation Using Singular Value Decomposition
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 131
(8
), p. 081006.31.
Van Eikema Hommes
, Q. D.
, 2008
, “Comparison and Application of Metrics That Define the Components Modularity in Complex Products
,” ASME
Paper No. DETC2008-49140.32.
Hölttä-Otto
, K.
, and de Weck
, O.
, 2007
, “Metrics for Assessing Coupling Density and Modularity in Complex Products and Systems
,” ASME
Paper No. DETC2007-34871.33.
Sinha
, K.
, Suh
, E. S.
, and de Weck
, O.
, 2018
, “Integrative Complexity: An Alternative Measure for System Modularity
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 140
(5
), p. 051101
.34.
Newman
, M.
, 2010
, Networks: An Introduction
, Oxford University Press
, Oxford, UK
.35.
Göhler
, S. M.
, Eifler
, T.
, and Howard
, T. J.
, 2016
, “Robustness Metrics: Consolidating the Multiple Approaches to Quantify Robustness
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 138
(11
), p. 111407
.36.
Kang
, N.
, Bayrak
, A. E.
, and Papalambros
, P. Y.
, 2018
, “Robustness and Real Options for Vehicle Design and Investment Decisions Under Gas Price and Regulatory Uncertainties
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 140
(10
), p. 101404
.37.
Nirmaier
, T.
, Kirscher
, J.
, Maksut
, Z.
, Harrant
, M.
, Rafaila
, M.
, and Pelz
, G.
, 2013
, “Robustness Metrics for Automotive Power Microelectronics
,” First RIIF Workshop at DATE13, Grenoble, France, Mar. 22.38.
Castro
, M. M.
, 2011
, “Metrics to Evaluate Network Robustness in Telecommunication Networks,” University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, Scotland, Report
.http://eia.udg.edu/~mmanzano/EINF/ManzanoMarc.pdf39.
Piraveenan
, M.
, Thedchanamoorthy
, G.
, Uddin
, S.
, and Chung
, K. S. K.
, 2013
, “Quantifying Topological Robustness of Networks Under Sustained Targeted Attacks
,” Soc. Network Anal. Min.
, 3
(4
), pp. 939
–952
.40.
Perry
, D.
, 2011
, Aircraft Structures
, Dover Publications
, Mineola, NY
.41.
Roskam
, J.
, 1985
, Airplane Design—Part 3
, DARcorporation
, Lawrence, KS
.42.
Gudmundsson
, S.
, 2013
, General Aviation Aircraft Design: Applied Methods and Procedures
, Butterworth-Heinemann
, Waltham, MA
.43.
Roskam
, J.
, 1985
, Airplane Design, Part 7
, DARcorporation
, Lawrence, KS
.44.
Stone
, R. B.
, Wood
, K. L.
, and Crawford
, R. H.
, 2000
, “A Heuristic Method for Identifying Modules for Product Architectures
,” Des. Stud.
, 21
(1
), pp. 5
–31
.Copyright © 2019 by ASME
You do not currently have access to this content.
